Are you looking for the best WordPress SEO plugin? If you are, then you have likely narrowed your choice down to the two most popular WordPress SEO plugins: Yoast SEO and All in One SEO Pack. At wpgooglebingo, we’re often asked which one is better? In this article, we will compare Yoast SEO vs All in One SEO Pack to find out which one is the best WordPress SEO plugin.
Installation and Setup
It takes a lot of training and practice to understand and successfully implement the concepts of SEO into websites. A WordPress SEO plugin should make it easy for beginners to setup SEO best practices without any special skills.
Let’s see how these two plugins stack up when it comes to installing and setting up basic SEO settings on WordPress websites.
Upon activation, users can go to SEO » Dashboard page and launch the configuration wizard under the General tab.
This will bring up a step by step wizard which will walk you through the setup process. This allows beginners to get started quickly without feeling overwhelmed by complex jargon and options.
Yoast SEO is a powerful plugin, and it has a lot of options that you need to go through one by one. We have made this easy for you, take a look at our guide on how to install and setup Yoast SEO plugin in WordPress.
The settings section of Yoast SEO is neatly divided into pages where each page has different tabs for respective settings.
This makes it easy for users to locate an option in the settings.
On screen help is available on all pages of Yoast SEO settings. Just click the purple Help button on the top, and it will expand to show video or text about the options on the page.
Neatly organized settings, configuration wizard for beginners, and on screen help options make it super easy for beginners to setup Yoast SEO on their WordPress site.
All in On SEO Pack
First, you need to install and activate All in One SEO Pack plugin. For more details, see our step by step guide on how to install a WordPress plugin.
Upon activation, you will find the All in One SEO menu item just below the Dashboard. Clicking on it will take you to plugin’s settings page.
All in One SEO Pack, has all the settings on a single page. This makes it look a bit overwhelming, but some users may find this approach easier and faster than the multi-page settings of Yoast SEO.
The settings page is divided into different sections. Each section deals with the settings of a particular area or feature, for example: homepage settings, title settings, display settings, etc.
There is a help icon next to each option. Clicking on the icon shows a short description and sometimes a link to additional documentation. This makes it easy for beginners to understand what they are doing.
Here is our user’s guide for All in Onev SEO Pack, which will help you properly setup the plugin.2
Once you have carefully gone through general settings, you are ready to use All in One SEO on your WordPress site.
Importing from All In One SEO Pack
The steps are simple:
- Install Yoast SEO (search for “Yoast SEO” in your backend and you should see it).
- Activate Yoast SEO.
- Disable All In One SEO pack.
- Go to SEO > Tools > Import & Export > Import from other SEO plugins, you’ll see this:
- Select the appropriate checkbox, in this case “Import from All-in-One SEO” and click “Import”.
- You’re done (with the automated part).
This imports all your data from All In One SEO Pack. Should this, for any reason what so ever, not work, then you can use the brilliant SEO Data Transporter plugin. This plugin allows you to move SEO data back and forth between several theme platforms and plugins, so it would also allow you to migrate to Yoast SEO from other plugins like Ultimate SEO.
All In One SEO Pack’s data is in, now what?
So after you’ve done this, you might want to setup title template, under SEO -> Search Appearance and enable the XML sitemaps, under SEO -> General -> XML Sitemaps. Our plugin now has an onboarding wizard, which wil guide you through the setup, asking you questions about your site and basing SEO decisions of that.
Why Yoast SEO beats All In One SEO Pack
Features like the snippet preview, SEO and readability analysis functionality and included XML sitemaps functionality make the plugin a true all in one SEO solution. You can even buy a Yoast SEO Premium subscription for even more awesome functionality, like internal linking suggestions and a fantastic redirects manager. Most importantly, our plugin helps you do better SEO. Good SEO means, in most cases, good content writing. Our plugin aims at supporting you with that as best as possible.
Are you using Google XML Sitemaps?
If you’re using Google XML sitemaps or another XML sitemaps plugin, you can just disable that and enable the XML sitemaps feature in Yoast SEO. The location changes with that, Google XML Sitemaps uses example.com/sitemap.xml, which is a static file, you can safely remove that. The new XML sitemap will be at example.com/sitemap_index.xml.
Successfully migrated? Great!
We love to hear from people who have switched over from All In One SEO Pack to Yoast SEO as to what worked for them, what could improve in the import process and what issues you might have had. If you have any tips for the process, please share them so everyone can benefit!